@article{doi:10.1139/facets-2016-0003, author = {Dick, Melissa and Rous, Andrew M. and Nguyen, Vivian M. and Cooke, Steven J.}, title = {Necessary but challenging: Multiple disciplinary approaches to solving conservation problems}, journal = {FACETS}, volume = {1}, number = {}, pages = {67-82}, year = {2017}, doi = {10.1139/facets-2016-0003}, URL = { https://doi.org/10.1139/facets-2016-0003 }, eprint = { https://doi.org/10.1139/facets-2016-0003 } , abstract = { Contemporary conservation problems are typically positioned at the interface of complex ecological and human systems. Traditional approaches aiming to compartmentalize a phenomenon within the confines of a single discipline and failing to engage non-science partners are outmoded and cannot identify solutions that have traction in the social, economic, and political arenas in which conservation actions must operate. As a result, conservation science teams must adopt multiple disciplinary approaches that bridge not only academic disciplines but also the political and social realms and engage relevant partners. Five reasons are presented that outline why conservation problems demand multiple disciplinary approaches in order to move forward because: (i) socio-ecological systems are complex, (ii) multiple perspectives are better than one, (iii) the results of research must influence practice, (iv) the heterogeneity of scale necessitates it, and (v) conservation involves compromise. Presenting reasons that support multiple disciplinarity demands a review of the barriers that impede this process, as we are far from attaining a model or framework that is applicable in all contexts. Two challenges that impede multiple disciplinarity are discussed, in addition to pragmatic solutions that conservation scientists and practitioners can adopt in their work. Overall, conservation researchers and practitioners are encouraged to explore the multiple disciplinary dimensions of their respective realms to more effectively solve problems in biodiversity and sustainability. } } @article {, author = {Allen CR}, author = {Gunderson LH}, title = {Pathology and failure in the design and implementation of adaptive management}, journal = {Journal of Environmental Management}, volume = {92}, pages = {1379}, year = {2011} } @article {, author = {Amey MJ}, author = {Brown DF}, title = {Interdisciplinary collaboration and academic work: a case study of a university-community partnership}, journal = {New Directions for Teaching and Learning}, volume = {2005}, pages = {23}, year = {2005} } @article {, author = {Andrade K}, author = {Corbin C}, author = {Diver S}, author = {Eitzel MV}, author = {Williamson J}, author = {Brasheres J}, author = {Fortmann J}, title = {Finding your way in the interdisciplinary forest: notes on educating future conservation practitioners}, journal = {Biodiversity and Conservation}, volume = {23}, pages = {3405}, year = {2014} } @article {, author = {Ben-Gal A}, author = {Weikard H-P}, author = {Shah SHH}, author = {van der Zee SEATM}, title = {A coupled agronomic-economic model to consider allocation of brackish irrigation water}, journal = {Water Resources Research}, volume = {49}, pages = {2861}, year = {2013} } @article {, author = {Bracken LJ}, author = {Oughton EA}, title = {‘What do you mean?’ The importance of language in developing interdisciplinary research}, journal = {Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers}, volume = {31}, pages = {371}, year = {2006} } @article {, author = {Brewer GD}, title = {The challenges of interdisciplinarity}, journal = {Policy Sciences}, volume = {32}, pages = {327}, year = {1999} } @article {, author = {Buller H}, title = {The lively process of interdisciplinarity}, journal = {Area}, volume = {41}, pages = {395}, year = {2009} } @article {, author = {Butchart SH}, author = {Walpole M}, author = {Collen B}, author = {van Strien A}, author = {Scharlemann JPW}, author = {Almond REA}, author = {Baillie JEM}, author = {Bomhard B}, author = {Brown C}, author = {Bruno J}, author = {Carpenter KE}, author = {Carr GM}, author = {Chanson C}, author = {Chenery AM}, author = {Csirke J}, author = {Davidson JN}, author = {Dentener F}, author = {Foster M}, author = {Galli A}, author = {Galloway JN}, author = {Genovesi P}, author = {Gregory RD}, author = {Hockings M}, author = {Kapos V}, author = {Lamarque J-F}, author = {Leverington F}, author = {Loh J}, author = {McGeoch MA}, author = {McRae L}, author = {Minaysan A}, author = {Hernández Morcillo M}, author = {Oldfield TEE}, author = {Pauly D}, author = {Quader S}, author = {Revenga C}, author = {Sauer JR}, author = {Skolnik B}, author = {Spear D}, author = {Stanwell-Smith D}, author = {Stuart SN}, author = {Symes A}, author = {Tierney M}, author = {Tyrrell TD}, author = {Vié J-C}, author = {Watson R}, title = {Global biodiversity: indicators of recent declines}, journal = {Science}, volume = {328}, pages = {1164}, year = {2010} } @article {, author = {Campbell LM}, title = {Overcoming obstacles to interdisciplinary research}, journal = {Conservation Biology}, volume = {19}, pages = {574}, year = {2005} } @article {, author = {Cash DW}, author = {Clark WC}, author = {Alcock W}, author = {Dickson NM}, author = {Eckley N}, author = {Guston D}, author = {Jager J}, author = {Mitchell R}, title = {Knowledge systems for sustainable development}, journal = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America}, volume = {100}, pages = {8086}, year = {2003} } @article {, author = {Chapman JM}, author = {Algera D}, author = {Dick M}, author = {Hawkins EE}, author = {Lawrence MJ}, author = {Lennox RJ}, author = {Rous AM}, author = {Souliere CM}, author = {Stemberger HLJ}, author = {Struthers DP}, author = {Vu M}, author = {Ward TD}, author = {Zolderdo AJ}, author = {Cooke SJ}, title = {Being relevant: practical guidance for early career researchers interested in solving conservation problems}, journal = {Global Ecology and Conservation}, volume = {4}, pages = {334}, year = {2015} } @article {, author = {Cook CN}, author = {Hockings M}, author = {Carter RW}, title = {Conservation in the dark? The information used to support management decisions}, journal = {Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment}, volume = {8}, pages = {181}, year = {2010} } @article {, author = {Cook CN}, author = {Mascia MB}, author = {Schwartz MW}, author = {Possingham HP}, author = {Fuller RA}, title = {Achieving conservation science that bridges the knowledge–action boundary}, journal = {Conservation Biology}, volume = {27}, pages = {669}, year = {2013} } @article {, author = {Cooke SJ}, author = {Killen SS}, author = {Metcalfe JD}, author = {McKenzie DJ}, author = {Mouillot D}, author = {Jørgensen C}, author = {Peck MA}, title = {Conservation physiology across scales: insights from the marine realm}, journal = {Conservation Physiology}, volume = {2}, pages = {1}, year = {2014} } @article {, author = {Daily GC}, author = {Ehrlich PR}, title = {Managing Earth’s ecosystems: an interdisciplinary challenge}, journal = {Ecosystems}, volume = {2}, pages = {277}, year = {1999} } @article {, author = {Day JC}, title = {Zoning—lessons from the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park}, journal = {Ocean and Coastal Management}, volume = {45}, pages = {139}, year = {2002} } @article {, author = {Demerouti E}, author = {Bakker AB}, author = {de Jonge J}, author = {Janssen PP}, author = {Schaufeli WB}, title = {Burnout and engagement at work as a function of demands and control}, journal = {Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health}, volume = {27}, pages = {279}, year = {2001} } @article {, author = {Fernandes L}, author = {Day J}, author = {Lewis A}, author = {Slegers S}, author = {Kerrigan B}, author = {Breen D}, author = {Cameron D}, author = {Jago B}, author = {Hall J}, author = {Lowe D}, author = {Innes J}, author = {Tanzer J}, author = {Chadwick V}, author = {Thompson L}, author = {Gorman K}, author = {Simmons M}, author = {Barnett B}, author = {Sampson K}, author = {De’Ath G}, author = {Mapstone B}, author = {Marsh H}, author = {Possingham H}, author = {Ball I}, author = {Ward T}, author = {Dobbs K}, author = {Aumend J}, author = {Slater D}, author = {Stapleton K}, title = {Establishing no-take areas in the Great Barrier Reef: large-scale implementation of theory on marine protected areas}, journal = {Conservation Biology}, volume = {19}, pages = {1733}, year = {2005} } @article {, author = {Fox HE}, author = {Christian C}, author = {Nordby JC}, author = {Pergams ORW}, author = {Peterson GD}, author = {Pyke CR}, title = {Perceived barriers to integrating social science and conservation}, journal = {Conservation Biology}, volume = {20}, pages = {1817}, year = {2006} } @article {, author = {Freitag A}, title = {Naming, framing, and blaming: exploring ways of knowing in the deceptively simple question “what is water quality?”}, journal = {Human Ecology}, volume = {42}, pages = {325}, year = {2014} } @article {, author = {Gewin V}, title = {Interdisciplinary research: break out}, journal = {Nature}, volume = {511}, pages = {371}, year = {2014} } @article {, author = {Greenwood JD}, title = {The monitoring of British breeding birds: a success story for conservation science?}, journal = {Science of the Total Environment}, volume = {310}, pages = {221}, year = {2003} } @article {, author = {Griggs D}, author = {Stafford-Smith M}, author = {Gaffney O}, author = {Rockström J}, author = {Öhman MC}, author = {Shyamsundar P}, author = {Steffen W}, author = {Glaser G}, author = {Kanie N}, author = {Noble I}, title = {Policy: sustainable development goals for people and planet}, journal = {Nature}, volume = {495}, pages = {305}, year = {2013} } @article {, author = {Gupta N}, author = {Bower SD}, author = {Raghaven R}, author = {Danylchuk AJ}, author = {Cooke SJ}, title = {Status of recreational fisheries in India: development, issues, and opportunities}, journal = {Reviews in Fisheries and Aquaculture}, volume = {23}, pages = {291}, year = {2015} } @article {, author = {Haapasaari P}, author = {Kulmala S}, author = {Kuikka S}, title = {Growing into interdisciplinarity: how to converge biology, economics, and social science in fisheries research?}, journal = {Ecology and Society}, volume = {17}, pages = {6}, year = {2012} } @article {, author = {Hadorn GH}, author = {Bradley D}, author = {Pohl C}, author = {Rist S}, author = {Wiesmann U}, title = {Implications of transdisciplinarity for sustainability research}, journal = {Ecological Economics}, volume = {60}, pages = {119}, year = {2006} } @article {, author = {Hooper DU}, author = {Adair EC}, author = {Cardinale BJ}, author = {Byrnes JEK}, author = {Hungate BA}, author = {Matulich KL}, author = {Gonzales A}, author = {Duffy JE}, author = {Gamfeldt L}, author = {O’Connor MI}, title = {A global synthesis reveals biodiversity loss as a major driver of ecosystem change}, journal = {Nature}, volume = {486}, pages = {105}, year = {2012} } @article {, author = {Huntington H}, title = {Using traditional ecological knowledge in science: methods and applications}, journal = {Ecological Applications}, volume = {10}, pages = {1270}, year = {2000} } @article {, author = {Kareiva P}, author = {Marvier M}, title = {What is conservation science?}, journal = {BioScience}, volume = {62}, pages = {962}, year = {2012} } @article {, author = {Keppel G}, author = {Morrison C}, author = {Watling D}, author = {Tuiwawa MV}, author = {Rounds IA}, title = {Conservation in tropical Pacific Island countries: why most current approaches are failing}, journal = {Conservation Letters}, volume = {5}, pages = {256}, year = {2012} } @article {, author = {Kurland NB}, author = {Michaud KE}, author = {Best M}, author = {Wohldmann E}, author = {Cox H}, author = {Pontikis K}, author = {Vasishth A}, title = {Overcoming silos: the role of an interdisciplinary course in shaping a sustainability network}, journal = {Academy of Management Learning and Education}, volume = {9}, pages = {457}, year = {2010} } @article {, author = {Landon AC}, author = {van Riper CJ}, author = {Anjeli NF}, author = {Fitzgerald DB}, author = {Neam KD}, title = {Growing transdisciplinary roots in the Peruvian Amazon: lessons from the field}, journal = {The Journal of Transdisciplinary Environmental Studies}, volume = {14}, pages = {2}, year = {2015} } @article {, author = {Lélé S}, author = {Norgaard RB}, title = {Practicing interdisciplinarity}, journal = {BioScience}, volume = {55}, pages = {967}, year = {2005} } @article {, author = {Liu J}, author = {Dietz T}, author = {Carpenter SR}, author = {Alberti M}, author = {Folke C}, author = {Moran E}, author = {Pell AN}, author = {Deadman P}, author = {Kratz T}, author = {Lubchenco J}, author = {Ostrom E}, author = {Ouyang Z}, author = {Provencher W}, author = {Redman CL}, author = {Schneider SH}, author = {Taylor WW}, title = {Complexity of coupled human and natural systems}, journal = {Science}, volume = {317}, pages = {1513}, year = {2007} } @article {, author = {Liu J}, author = {Linderman M}, author = {Ouyang Z}, author = {An L}, author = {Yang J}, author = {Zhang H}, title = {Ecological degradation in protected areas: the case of Wolong Nature Reserve for Giant Pandas}, journal = {Science}, volume = {292}, pages = {98}, year = {2001} } @article {, author = {Liu J}, author = {Ouyang Z}, author = {Taylor WW}, author = {Groop R}, author = {Tan Y}, author = {Zhang H}, title = {A framework for evaluating the effects of human factors on wildlife habitat: the case of Giant Pandas}, journal = {Conservation Biology}, volume = {13}, pages = {1360}, year = {1999} } @article {, author = {Luks F}, author = {Siebenhüner B}, title = {Transdisciplinarity for social learning? The contribution of the German socio-ecological research initiative to sustainability governance}, journal = {Ecological Economics}, volume = {63}, pages = {418}, year = {2007} } @article {, author = {Lynch J}, title = {It’s not easy being interdisciplinary}, journal = {International Journal of Epidemiology}, volume = {35}, pages = {1119}, year = {2006} } @article {, author = {Mallegowda P}, title = {Interdisciplinary research: way forward for biodiversity conservation}, journal = {Current Science}, volume = {105}, pages = {1202}, year = {2013} } @article {, author = {Mascia MB}, author = {Brosius JP}, author = {Dobson TA}, author = {Forbes BC}, author = {Horowitz L}, author = {McKean MA}, author = {Turner NJ}, title = {Conservation and the social sciences}, journal = {Conservation Biology}, volume = {17}, pages = {649}, year = {2003} } @article {, author = {Max-Neef MA}, title = {Foundations of transdisciplinarity}, journal = {Ecological Economics}, volume = {53}, pages = {5}, year = {2005} } @article {, author = {Metzger N}, author = {Zare RN}, title = {Interdisciplinary research: from belief to reality}, journal = {Science}, volume = {283}, pages = {642}, year = {1999} } @article {, author = {Miller BW}, author = {Caplow SC}, author = {Leslie PW}, title = {Feedbacks between conservation and social-ecological systems}, journal = {Conservation Biology}, volume = {26}, pages = {218}, year = {2012} } @article {, author = {Miller RG}, author = {Hutchison ZL}, author = {Macleod AK}, author = {Burrows MT}, author = {Cook EJ}, author = {Last KS}, author = {Wilson B}, title = {Marine renewable energy development: assessing the Benthic Footprint at multiple scales}, journal = {Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment}, volume = {11}, pages = {433}, year = {2013} } @article {, author = {Miller TR}, author = {Baird TD}, author = {Littlefield CM}, author = {Kofinas G}, author = {Chapin FS}, author = {Redman CL}, title = {Epistemological pluralism: reorganizing interdisciplinary research}, journal = {Ecology and Society}, volume = {13}, pages = {46}, year = {2008} } @article {, author = {Naeem S}, title = {Ecosystem consequences of biodiversity loss: the evolution of a paradigm}, journal = {Ecology}, volume = {83}, pages = {1537}, year = {2002} } @article {, author = {Naiman RJ}, title = {A perspective on interdisciplinary science}, journal = {Ecosystems}, volume = {2}, pages = {292}, year = {1999} } @article {, author = {Pooley SP}, author = {Mendelsohn JA}, author = {Milner-Gulland EJ}, title = {Hunting down the chimera of multiple disciplinarity in conservation science}, journal = {Conservation Biology}, volume = {28}, pages = {22}, year = {2014} } @article {, author = {Regan HM}, author = {Ben-Haim Y}, author = {Langford B}, author = {Wilson WG}, author = {Lundberg P}, author = {Andelman SJ}, author = {Burgman MA}, title = {Robust decision-making under severe uncertainty for conservation management}, journal = {Ecological Applications}, volume = {15}, pages = {1471}, year = {2005} } @article {, author = {Reyers B}, author = {Roux DJ}, author = {Cowling RM}, author = {Ginsburg AE}, author = {Nel JL}, author = {O’Farrell P}, title = {Conservation planning as a transdisciplinary process}, journal = {Conservation Biology}, volume = {24}, pages = {957}, year = {2010} } @article {, author = {Rhoten D}, author = {Parker A}, title = {Risks and rewards of an interdisciplinary research path}, journal = {Science}, volume = {306}, pages = {2046}, year = {2004} } @article {, author = {Rittel HWJ}, author = {Webber MM}, title = {Dilemmas in a general theory of planning}, journal = {Policy Sciences}, volume = {4}, pages = {155}, year = {1973} } @article {, author = {Roy ED}, author = {Morzillo AT}, author = {Seijo F}, author = {Reddy SMW}, author = {Rhemtulla JM}, author = {Milder JC}, author = {Kuemmerle T}, author = {Martin SL}, title = {The elusive pursuit of interdisciplinarity at the human-environment interface}, journal = {BioScience}, volume = {63}, pages = {745}, year = {2013} } @article {, author = {Sandbrook C}, author = {Adams WM}, author = {Büscher B}, author = {Vira B}, title = {Social research and biodiversity conservation}, journal = {Conservation Biology}, volume = {27}, pages = {1487}, year = {2013} } @article {, author = {Schäfer RB}, author = {Cooke SJ}, author = {Arlinghaus R}, author = {Bonada N}, author = {Brischoux F}, author = {Casper AF}, author = {Catford JA}, author = {Rolland V}, title = {Perspectives from early career researchers on the publication process in ecology—a response to Statzner \& Resh (2010)}, journal = {Freshwater Biology}, volume = {56}, pages = {2405}, year = {2011} } @article {, author = {Soulé ME}, title = {What is conservation biology?: A new synthetic discipline addresses the dynamics and problems of perturbed species, communities, and ecosystems}, journal = {BioScience}, volume = {35}, pages = {727}, year = {1985} } @article {, author = {Steffen W}, author = {Crutzen PJ}, author = {McNeill JR}, title = {The Anthropocene: are humans now overwhelming the great forces of nature}, journal = {AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment}, volume = {36}, pages = {614}, year = {2007} } @article {, author = {Stock P}, author = {Burton RJF}, title = {Defining terms for integrated (multi-inter-trans-disciplinary) sustainability research}, journal = {Sustainability}, volume = {3}, pages = {1090}, year = {2011} } @article {, author = {Strang V}, title = {Integrating the social and natural sciences in environmental research: a discussion paper}, journal = {Environment, Development and Sustainability}, volume = {11}, pages = {1}, year = {2009} } @article {, author = {Sutherland WJ}, author = {Gardner TA}, author = {Haider LJ}, author = {Dicks LV}, title = {How can local and traditional knowledge be effectively incorporated into international assessments?}, journal = {Oryx}, volume = {48}, pages = {1}, year = {2014} } @article {, author = {Sutherland WJ}, author = {Pullin AS}, author = {Dolman PM}, author = {Knight TM}, title = {The need for evidence-based conservation}, journal = {Trends in Ecology \& Evolution}, volume = {19}, pages = {305}, year = {2004} } @article {, author = {Tress G}, author = {Tress B}, author = {Fry G}, title = {Clarifying integrative research concepts in landscape ecology}, journal = {Landscape Ecology}, volume = {20}, pages = {479}, year = {2005} } @article {, author = {Vitousek PM}, author = {Mooney HA}, author = {Lubchenco J}, author = {Melillo JM}, title = {Human domination of Earth’s ecosystems}, journal = {Science}, volume = {277}, pages = {494}, year = {1997} } @article {, author = {Walters CJ}, author = {Holling CS}, title = {Large-scale management experiments and learning by doing}, journal = {Ecology}, volume = {71}, pages = {2060}, year = {1990} } @article {, author = {Zalasiewicz J}, author = {Williams M}, author = {Haywood A}, author = {Ellis M}, title = {The Anthropocene: a new epoch of geological time?}, journal = {Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences}, volume = {369}, pages = {835}, year = {2011} }