@article{doi:10.1139/facets-2016-0007, author = {Conrad, Cheyenne C. and Stanford, Kim and McAllister, Tim A. and Thomas, James and Reuter, Tim}, title = {Competition during enrichment of pathogenic Escherichia coli may result in culture bias}, journal = {FACETS}, volume = {1}, number = {}, pages = {114-126}, year = {2017}, doi = {10.1139/facets-2016-0007}, URL = { https://doi.org/10.1139/facets-2016-0007 }, eprint = { https://doi.org/10.1139/facets-2016-0007 } , abstract = { Deadly outbreaks and illnesses due to Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli (STEC) occur worldwide; however, the cultivation methods required for adequate monitoring and traceback investigations are inefficient at best. Detection of STEC relies heavily on enrichment; yet no standard media or protocols exist. Furthermore, whether enrichment may bias detection of multiple STEC serogroups from complex samples is unknown. Thus, 14 STEC strains of serogroups O157 and the top six non-O157s (O26, O45, O103, O111, O121, and O145) were enriched in pairs for 6–78 h in broth and evaluated by quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR). Here we show that a conventional 6-h enrichment protocol did not result in intra-species culture bias for the isolates tested. However, subsequent enrichments often produced biased cultures, with differences in the qPCR gene copy number ≥2 log10 apparent in 12\%, 38\%, and 52\% of competitions after 30, 54, and 78 h of consecutive enrichments, respectively. Some strains were able to prevail and (or) out-compete the opponent strain in 100\% of competitions. Our results suggest that culture bias should be considered and (or) evaluated further due to the potential implications during routine pathogen screening and outbreak investigations. } } @article {, author = {Akerlund T}, author = {Nordström K}, author = {Bernander R}, title = {Analysis of cell size and DNA content in exponentially growing and stationary-phase batch cultures of Escherichia coli}, journal = {Journal of Bacteriology}, volume = {177}, pages = {6791}, year = {1995} } @article {, author = {Bai J}, author = {Paddock ZD}, author = {Shi X}, author = {Li S}, author = {An B}, author = {Nagaraja TG}, title = {Applicability of a multiplex PCR to detect the seven major Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli based on genes that code for serogroup-specific O-antigens and major virulence factors in cattle feces}, journal = {Foodborne Pathogens and Disease}, volume = {9}, pages = {541}, year = {2012} } @article {, author = {Bettelheim KA}, title = {The non-O157 Shiga-toxigenic (verocytotoxigenic) Escherichia coli; under-rated pathogens}, journal = {Critical Reviews in Microbiology}, volume = {33}, pages = {67}, year = {2007} } @article {, author = {Boye E}, author = {Lobner-Olesen A}, title = {Bacterial growth control studied by flow cytometry}, journal = {Research in Microbiology}, volume = {142}, pages = {131}, year = {1991} } @article {, author = {Carter MQ}, author = {Brandl MT}, author = {Louie JW}, author = {Kyle JL}, author = {Carychao DK}, author = {Cooley MB}, author = {Parker CT}, author = {Bates AH}, author = {Mandrell RE}, title = {Distinct acid resistance and survival fitness displayed by Curli variants of enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli O157:H7}, journal = {Applied and Environmental Microbiology}, volume = {77}, pages = {3685}, year = {2011} } @article {, author = {Conrad CC}, author = {Gilroyed BH}, author = {McAllister TA}, author = {Reuter T}, title = {Synthesis of O-serogroup specific positive controls and real-time PCR standards for nine clinically relevant non-O157 STECs}, journal = {Journal of Microbiological Methods}, volume = {91}, pages = {52}, year = {2012} } @article {, author = {Conrad CC}, author = {Stanford K}, author = {McAllister TA}, author = {Thomas J}, author = {Reuter T}, title = {Further development of sample preparation and detection methods for O157 and the top 6 non-O157 STEC serogroups in cattle feces}, journal = {Journal of Microbiological Methods}, volume = {105}, pages = {22}, year = {2014} } @article {, author = {Cooley MB}, author = {Jay-Russell M}, author = {Atwill ER}, author = {Carychao D}, author = {Nguyen K}, author = {Quiñones B}, author = {Patel R}, author = {Walker S}, author = {Swimley M}, author = {Pierre-Jerome E}, author = {Gordus AG}, author = {Mandrell RE}, title = {Development of a robust method for isolation of Shiga toxin-positive Escherichia coli (STEC) from fecal, plant, soil and water samples from a leafy greens production region in California}, journal = {PLoS One}, volume = {8}, pages = {e65716}, year = {2013} } @article {, author = {Dunbar J}, author = {White S}, author = {Forney L}, title = {Genetic diversity through the looking glass: effect of enrichment bias}, journal = {Applied and Environmental Microbiology}, volume = {63}, pages = {1326}, year = {1997} } @article {, author = {Durso LM}, title = {Primary isolation of Shiga toxigenic Escherichia coli from environmental sources}, journal = {Journal of Environmental Quality}, volume = {42}, pages = {1295}, year = {2013} } @article {, author = {Eydallin G}, author = {Ryall B}, author = {Maharjan R}, author = {Ferenci T}, title = {The nature of laboratory domestication changes in freshly isolated Escherichia coli strains}, journal = {Environmental Microbiology}, volume = {16}, pages = {813}, year = {2014} } @article {, author = {Franz E}, author = {Delaquis P}, author = {Morabito S}, author = {Beutin L}, author = {Gobius K}, author = {Rasko DA}, author = {Bono J}, author = {French N}, author = {Osek J}, author = {Lindstedt BA}, author = {Muniesa M}, author = {Manning S}, author = {LeJeune J}, author = {Callaway T}, author = {Beatson S}, author = {Eppinger M}, author = {Dallman T}, author = {Forbes KJ}, author = {Aarts H}, author = {Pearl DL}, author = {Gannon VP}, author = {Laing CR}, author = {Strachan NJ}, title = {Exploiting the explosion of information associated with whole genome sequencing to tackle Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli (STEC) in global food production systems}, journal = {International Journal of Food Microbiology}, volume = {187}, pages = {57}, year = {2014} } @article {, author = {Gill A}, author = {Gill CO}, title = {Non-O157 verotoxigenic Escherichia coli and beef: a Canadian perspective}, journal = {Canadian Journal of Veterinary Research}, volume = {74}, pages = {161}, year = {2010} } @article {, author = {Gorski L}, title = {Selective enrichment media bias the types of Salmonella enterica strains isolated from mixed strain cultures and complex enrichment broths}, journal = {PLoS One}, volume = {7}, pages = {e34722}, year = {2012} } @article {, author = {Hussein HS}, title = {Prevalence and pathogenicity of Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli in beef cattle and their products}, journal = {Journal of Animal Science}, volume = {85}, pages = {E63}, year = {2007} } @article {, author = {Kaspar C}, author = {Doyle ME}, author = {Archer J}, title = {White paper on non-O157: H7 Shiga toxin-producing E. coli from meat and non-meat sources}, journal = {Food Research Institute Food Safety Reviews}, volume = {}, pages = {}, year = {2010} } @article {, author = {Lainhart W}, author = {Stolfa G}, author = {Koudelka GB}, title = {Shiga toxin as a bacterial defense against a eukaryotic predator, Tetrahymena thermophila}, journal = {Journal of Bacteriology}, volume = {191}, pages = {5116}, year = {2009} } @article {, author = {Lin A}, author = {Sultan O}, author = {Lau HK}, author = {Wong E}, author = {Hartman G}, author = {Lauzon CR}, title = {O serogroup specific real time PCR assays for the detection and identification of nine clinically relevant non-O157 STECs}, journal = {Food Microbiology}, volume = {28}, pages = {478}, year = {2011} } @article {, author = {Liu B}, author = {Yin X}, author = {Feng Y}, author = {Chambers JR}, author = {Guo A}, author = {Gong J}, author = {Zhu J}, author = {Gyles CL}, title = {Verotoxin 2 enhances adherence of enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli O157: H7 to intestinal epithelial cells and expression of β1-integrin by IPEC-J2 cells}, journal = {Applied and Environmental Microbiology}, volume = {76}, pages = {4461}, year = {2010} } @article {, author = {Martínez-Castillo A}, author = {Muniesa M}, title = {Implications of free Shiga toxin-converting bacteriophages occurring outside bacteria for the evolution and the detection of Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli}, journal = {Frontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology}, volume = {4}, pages = {46}, year = {2014} } @article {, author = {Mathusa EC}, author = {Chen Y}, author = {Enache E}, author = {Hontz L}, title = {Non-O157 Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli in foods}, journal = {Journal of Food Protection}, volume = {73}, pages = {1721}, year = {2010} } @article {, author = {Muniesa M}, author = {Blanch AR}, author = {Lucena F}, author = {Jofre J}, title = {Bacteriophages may bias outcome of bacterial enrichment cultures}, journal = {Applied and Environmental Microbiology}, volume = {71}, pages = {4269}, year = {2005} } @article {, author = {Paddock Z}, author = {Shi X}, author = {Bai J}, author = {Nagaraja TG}, title = {Applicability of a multiplex PCR to detect O26, O45, O103, O111, O121, O145, and O157 serogroups of Escherichia coli in cattle feces}, journal = {Veterinary Microbiology}, volume = {156}, pages = {381}, year = {2012} } @article {, author = {Pettengill JB}, author = {McAvoy E}, author = {White JR}, author = {Allard M}, author = {Brown E}, author = {Ottesen A}, title = {Using metagenomic analyses to estimate the consequences of enrichment bias for pathogen detection}, journal = {BMC Research Notes}, volume = {5}, pages = {378}, year = {2012} } @article {, author = {Possé B}, author = {De Zutter L}, author = {Heyndrickx M}, author = {Herman L}, title = {Novel differential and confirmation plating media for Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli serotypes O26, O103, O111, O145 and sorbitol-positive and -negative O157}, journal = {FEMS Microbiology Letters}, volume = {282}, pages = {124}, year = {2008} } @article {, author = {Sidari R}, author = {Caridi A}, title = {Methods for detecting enterohaemorrhagic Escherichia coli in food}, journal = {Food Reviews International}, volume = {27}, pages = {134}, year = {2011} } @article {, author = {Singer RS}, author = {Mayer AE}, author = {Hanson TE}, author = {Isaacson RE}, title = {Do microbial interactions and cultivation media decrease the accuracy of Salmonella surveillance systems and outbreak investigations?}, journal = {Journal of Food Protection}, volume = {72}, pages = {707}, year = {2009} } @article {, author = {Snedeker KG}, author = {Shaw DJ}, author = {Locking ME}, author = {Prescott RJ}, title = {Primary and secondary cases in Escherichia coli O157 outbreaks: a statistical analysis}, journal = {BMC Infectious Diseases}, volume = {9}, pages = {144}, year = {2009} } @article {, author = {Vimont A}, author = {Vernozy-Rozand C}, author = {Delignette-Muller ML}, title = {Isolation of E. coli O157:H7 and non-O157 STEC in different matrices: review of the most commonly used enrichment protocols}, journal = {Letters in Applied Microbiology}, volume = {42}, pages = {102}, year = {2006} } @article {, author = {Vimont A}, author = {Vernozy-Rozand C}, author = {Montet MP}, author = {Bavai C}, author = {Fremaux B}, author = {Delignette-Muller ML}, title = {Growth of Shiga-toxin producing Escherichia coli (STEC) and bovine feces background microflora in various enrichment protocols}, journal = {Veterinary Microbiology}, volume = {123}, pages = {274}, year = {2007} }